Merge #11512: Use GetDesireableServiceFlags in seeds, dnsseeds, fixing static seed adding

2b839ab Update chainparams comment for more info on service bits per dnsseed (Matt Corallo)
62e7642 Fall back to oneshot for DNS Seeds which don't support filtering. (Matt Corallo)
51ae766 Use GetDesireableServiceFlags in static seeds, document this. (Matt Corallo)
fb6f6b1 bluematt's testnet-seed now supports x9 (and is just a static list) (Matt Corallo)

Pull request description:

  4440710 broke inserting entries into addrman from dnsseeds which
  did not support service bits, as well as static seeds. Static seeds
  were already being filtered by UA for 0.13.1+ (ie NODE_WITNESS), so
  simply changing the default service bits to include NODE_WITNESS
  (and updating docs appropriately) is sufficient. For DNS Seeds, not
  supporting NODE_WITNESS is no longer useful, so instead use
  non-filtering seeds as oneshot hosts irrespective of named proxy.

  I've set my testnet-seed to also support x9, though because it is simply a static host, it may be useful to leave the support off so that it is used as a oneshot to get addresses from a live node instead. I'm fine with either.

Tree-SHA512: 3f17d4d2b0b84d876981c962d2b44cb0c8f95f52c56a48c6b35fd882f6d7a40805f320ec452985a1c0b34aebddb1922709156c3ceccd1b9f8363fd7cb537d21d

4 files changed, 36 insertions, 38 deletions

diff --git a/src/chainparams.cpp b/src/chainparams.cpp
index 97a6c346ab..39757baf9e 100644
--- a/src/chainparams.cpp
+++ b/src/chainparams.cpp
@@ -124,13 +124,17 @@ public:
         assert(consensus.hashGenesisBlock == uint256S("0x000000000019d6689c085ae165831e934ff763ae46a2a6c172b3f1b60a8ce26f"));
         assert(genesis.hashMerkleRoot == uint256S("0x4a5e1e4baab89f3a32518a88c31bc87f618f76673e2cc77ab2127b7afdeda33b"));
 
-        // Note that of those with the service bits flag, most only support a subset of possible options
-        vSeeds.emplace_back("seed.bitcoin.sipa.be", true); // Pieter Wuille, only supports x1, x5, x9, and xd
-        vSeeds.emplace_back("dnsseed.bluematt.me", true); // Matt Corallo, only supports x9
-        vSeeds.emplace_back("dnsseed.bitcoin.dashjr.org", false); // Luke Dashjr
-        vSeeds.emplace_back("seed.bitcoinstats.com", true); // Christian Decker, supports x1 - xf
-        vSeeds.emplace_back("seed.bitcoin.jonasschnelli.ch", true); // Jonas Schnelli, only supports x1, x5, x9, and xd
-        vSeeds.emplace_back("seed.btc.petertodd.org", true); // Peter Todd, only supports x1, x5, x9, and xd
+        // Note that of those which support the service bits prefix, most only support a subset of
+        // possible options.
+        // This is fine at runtime as we'll fall back to using them as a oneshot if they dont support the
+        // service bits we want, but we should get them updated to support all service bits wanted by any
+        // release ASAP to avoid it where possible.
+        vSeeds.emplace_back("seed.bitcoin.sipa.be"); // Pieter Wuille, only supports x1, x5, x9, and xd
+        vSeeds.emplace_back("dnsseed.bluematt.me"); // Matt Corallo, only supports x9
+        vSeeds.emplace_back("dnsseed.bitcoin.dashjr.org"); // Luke Dashjr
+        vSeeds.emplace_back("seed.bitcoinstats.com"); // Christian Decker, supports x1 - xf
+        vSeeds.emplace_back("seed.bitcoin.jonasschnelli.ch"); // Jonas Schnelli, only supports x1, x5, x9, and xd
+        vSeeds.emplace_back("seed.btc.petertodd.org"); // Peter Todd, only supports x1, x5, x9, and xd
 
         base58Prefixes[PUBKEY_ADDRESS] = std::vector<unsigned char>(1,0);
         base58Prefixes[SCRIPT_ADDRESS] = std::vector<unsigned char>(1,5);
@@ -229,10 +233,10 @@ public:
         vFixedSeeds.clear();
         vSeeds.clear();
         // nodes with support for servicebits filtering should be at the top
-        vSeeds.emplace_back("testnet-seed.bitcoin.jonasschnelli.ch", true);
-        vSeeds.emplace_back("seed.tbtc.petertodd.org", true);
-        vSeeds.emplace_back("seed.testnet.bitcoin.sprovoost.nl", true);
-        vSeeds.emplace_back("testnet-seed.bluematt.me", false);
+        vSeeds.emplace_back("testnet-seed.bitcoin.jonasschnelli.ch");
+        vSeeds.emplace_back("seed.tbtc.petertodd.org");
+        vSeeds.emplace_back("seed.testnet.bitcoin.sprovoost.nl");
+        vSeeds.emplace_back("testnet-seed.bluematt.me"); // Just a static list of stable node(s), only supports x9
 
         base58Prefixes[PUBKEY_ADDRESS] = std::vector<unsigned char>(1,111);
         base58Prefixes[SCRIPT_ADDRESS] = std::vector<unsigned char>(1,196);
diff --git a/src/chainparams.h b/src/chainparams.h
index ecfe1a0ac3..d478da9891 100644
--- a/src/chainparams.h
+++ b/src/chainparams.h
@@ -14,12 +14,6 @@
 #include <memory>
 #include <vector>
 
-struct CDNSSeedData {
-    std::string host;
-    bool supportsServiceBitsFiltering;
-    CDNSSeedData(const std::string &strHost, bool supportsServiceBitsFilteringIn) : host(strHost), supportsServiceBitsFiltering(supportsServiceBitsFilteringIn) {}
-};
-
 struct SeedSpec6 {
     uint8_t addr[16];
     uint16_t port;
@@ -71,7 +65,8 @@ public:
     bool MineBlocksOnDemand() const { return fMineBlocksOnDemand; }
     /** Return the BIP70 network string (main, test or regtest) */
     std::string NetworkIDString() const { return strNetworkID; }
-    const std::vector<CDNSSeedData>& DNSSeeds() const { return vSeeds; }
+    /** Return the list of hostnames to look up for DNS seeds */
+    const std::vector<std::string>& DNSSeeds() const { return vSeeds; }
     const std::vector<unsigned char>& Base58Prefix(Base58Type type) const { return base58Prefixes[type]; }
     const std::string& Bech32HRP() const { return bech32_hrp; }
     const std::vector<SeedSpec6>& FixedSeeds() const { return vFixedSeeds; }
@@ -85,7 +80,7 @@ protected:
     CMessageHeader::MessageStartChars pchMessageStart;
     int nDefaultPort;
     uint64_t nPruneAfterHeight;
-    std::vector<CDNSSeedData> vSeeds;
+    std::vector<std::string> vSeeds;
     std::vector<unsigned char> base58Prefixes[MAX_BASE58_TYPES];
     std::string bech32_hrp;
     std::string strNetworkID;
diff --git a/src/net.cpp b/src/net.cpp
index 682f47bff2..8111390749 100644
--- a/src/net.cpp
+++ b/src/net.cpp
@@ -136,7 +136,7 @@ static std::vector<CAddress> convertSeed6(const std::vector<SeedSpec6> &vSeedsIn
     for (const auto& seed_in : vSeedsIn) {
         struct in6_addr ip;
         memcpy(&ip, seed_in.addr, sizeof(ip));
-        CAddress addr(CService(ip, seed_in.port), NODE_NETWORK);
+        CAddress addr(CService(ip, seed_in.port), GetDesirableServiceFlags(NODE_NONE));
         addr.nTime = GetTime() - GetRand(nOneWeek) - nOneWeek;
         vSeedsOut.push_back(addr);
     }
@@ -1577,19 +1577,6 @@ void MapPort(bool)
 
 
 
-static std::string GetDNSHost(const CDNSSeedData& data, ServiceFlags* requiredServiceBits)
-{
-    //use default host for non-filter-capable seeds or if we use the default service bits (NODE_NETWORK)
-    if (!data.supportsServiceBitsFiltering || *requiredServiceBits == NODE_NETWORK) {
-        *requiredServiceBits = NODE_NETWORK;
-        return data.host;
-    }
-
-    // See chainparams.cpp, most dnsseeds only support one or two possible servicebits hostnames
-    return strprintf("x%x.%s", *requiredServiceBits, data.host);
-}
-
-
 void CConnman::ThreadDNSAddressSeed()
 {
     // goal: only query DNS seeds if address need is acute
@@ -1612,22 +1599,22 @@ void CConnman::ThreadDNSAddressSeed()
         }
     }
 
-    const std::vector<CDNSSeedData> &vSeeds = Params().DNSSeeds();
+    const std::vector<std::string> &vSeeds = Params().DNSSeeds();
     int found = 0;
 
     LogPrintf("Loading addresses from DNS seeds (could take a while)\n");
 
-    for (const CDNSSeedData &seed : vSeeds) {
+    for (const std::string &seed : vSeeds) {
         if (interruptNet) {
             return;
         }
         if (HaveNameProxy()) {
-            AddOneShot(seed.host);
+            AddOneShot(seed);
         } else {
             std::vector<CNetAddr> vIPs;
             std::vector<CAddress> vAdd;
             ServiceFlags requiredServiceBits = GetDesirableServiceFlags(NODE_NONE);
-            std::string host = GetDNSHost(seed, &requiredServiceBits);
+            std::string host = strprintf("x%x.%s", requiredServiceBits, seed);
             CNetAddr resolveSource;
             if (!resolveSource.SetInternal(host)) {
                 continue;
@@ -1643,6 +1630,10 @@ void CConnman::ThreadDNSAddressSeed()
                     found++;
                 }
                 addrman.Add(vAdd, resolveSource);
+            } else {
+                // We now avoid directly using results from DNS Seeds which do not support service bit filtering,
+                // instead using them as a oneshot to get nodes with our desired service bits.
+                AddOneShot(seed);
             }
         }
     }
diff --git a/src/protocol.h b/src/protocol.h
index 452b5b28ce..43d8ac067a 100644
--- a/src/protocol.h
+++ b/src/protocol.h
@@ -291,7 +291,15 @@ enum ServiceFlags : uint64_t {
  * unless they set NODE_NETWORK_LIMITED and we are out of IBD, in which
  * case NODE_NETWORK_LIMITED suffices).
  *
- * Thus, generally, avoid calling with peerServices == NODE_NONE.
+ * Thus, generally, avoid calling with peerServices == NODE_NONE, unless
+ * state-specific flags must absolutely be avoided. When called with
+ * peerServices == NODE_NONE, the returned desirable service flags are
+ * guaranteed to not change dependant on state - ie they are suitable for
+ * use when describing peers which we know to be desirable, but for which
+ * we do not have a confirmed set of service flags.
+ *
+ * If the NODE_NONE return value is changed, contrib/seeds/makeseeds.py
+ * should be updated appropriately to filter for the same nodes.
  */
 static ServiceFlags GetDesirableServiceFlags(ServiceFlags services) {
     return ServiceFlags(NODE_NETWORK | NODE_WITNESS);